Monday, March 8, 2010
Response: disease surveillance focuses on palms, undercover bugs
This is my first article on the environmental aspects of Chagas disease. I am far more comfortable with Ecology than I am with Public Health, so I enjoy their combination. Ecological management and education is vital in all parts of the world, but that it could have such a profound effect on peoples health is incredible. But once again, the simple solutions are the ones with the greatest effect. Cleaning palm trees, unexpected, but not challenging considering the size of an average palm is little more than thirty feet. So perhaps education and ecological cleanliness can be added to the list of must do's to solve Chagas disease.
notes: Chagas disease surveillance focuses on palms, undercover bugs
- "The burden of Chagas disease in the Latin American-Caribbean region is still consistently larger than the combined burden of malaria, leprosy, the leishmaniases, lymphatic filariasis, onchocerciasis, schistosomiasis, viral hepatitides B and C, dengue, and the major intestinal nematode infections,"
- the insect vectors of Chagas are triatomine bugs
- triatomine bugs usually infest low quality housing in rural and peri- urban regions
- triatomine bugs' domestic tendencies make them easy to find and kill
- insecticide spraying campaigns have halted the spread of Chagas throughout much of South America
- In Amizonia however, this is not possible, triatomine bugs breed in palm trees there
- figuring out whether or not any specific palm tree is infected is challenging, triatomine bugs are small and brown and are therefore hard to find.
- this knowledge has allowed public health officials on the ground to better accertain the location of an infestation, the colony responsible for an outbreak of Chagas is likely within short walking distance of the first household infected.
- SIMPLE environmental management practices such as removing debris from the crowns of palm trees has the potential to greatly decrease the risk of an infestation
Completed Interview Q&A With ms. Katherine Gormley
1. Which, if any, of the following contributors to NTD's has the greatest effect on the spread of NTD's in Latin America: the lack of vaccines or cures for many of the NTD's, poverty, sanitation, corrupted politics, geopolitics or the lack of doctors.I think the sheer lack of funding and attention paid to NTDs is what is the main problem. Most people don't even know these diseases exist, or still exist. Leprosy, is kind of like the bogeyman of Sunday School; everyone and their dog comes down with it in the New Testament but then we never see it again. At least the Bible you have a cure, given by Jesus of course, but he's kinda a magic bullet. However, in public health there really isn't one factor you can improve and expect results, no magic bullet, no wandering Son of God. So I guess it's a combination of all of them, but more on the poverty/sanitation/geopolitics side, which are all intertwined anyway, as you probably know.
2. From the above, which factor(s) would you consider the easiest fix?
Sanitation is probably the easiest from a systemic fixing stand-point, but it's not very elegant and won't raise funds well. No one really wants to talk about clean water systems or stable housing infrastructure or oral re-hydration pills because they aren't "sexy" and don't make for a good keynote at a benefit banquet. It's much easier to raise money for vaccines, but logistically easier (and faster) to distribute iodine tablets or create clean water infrastructure. Unfortunately, creation of vaccines tends to lead to the funds being allocated to scientists in the "developed" worlds, rather than going more directly to the people who could use some money now for infrastructure.
3. From the above, which factor(s) is/are the most important to be tackled in the short term?
Once again, sanitation. It's crappy to talk about poop all the time, but it really matters to humans where we put it. Take hook-worm, for example. You get it from worms in (mostly) human feces which burrow into your bare feet as you defecate in the same--uncovered and not sanitary--place every day. It really matters, right?
But when I say, "fix sanitation," you don't always have to suddenly create 3-tiered water filtration systems and waste-disposal plants with fecal cleaning algae. Solutions can be a lot simpler than that. In our hookworm example, the way that the USA got rid of the raging hookworm in the south in the 1960s was to give kids shoes (and more food, but that's actually ancillary to the subject). By giving children shoes, the hookworms were prevented their method of entry and propagation and the incidence of hookworm declined rapidly in the USA.
4. From the above, which factor(s) is/are the most important to be tackled in the long term?
Poverty Poverty Poverty. Every generation of economists and bleeding-heart liberals (most often the two are not in the same group) has a version of how to solve the "Poverty Question," which have sometimes improved the impoverished but in many cases--like structural re-adjustment theory, that 20th century IMF Latin American disaster of a financial policy--have made things drastically worse for impoverished countries. I am personally in favor of the new trend in "micro-financing" as a method of ameliorating poverty.
I love the gender question. We answer it all the time at Smith, because it is an often forgotten (though of increasing importance) lens through which one can view any issue. I wouldn't say that being a woman (or man) really pre-disposes one towards contracting certain NTDs, although it is a pretty wide spectrum, NTDs. I would say, however, that the consequences for falling ill with one of these diseases has unique--not necessarily worse but different--ramifications for women as opposed to men.
5. What role does gender play in the spread and treatment of NTD's? (please, only a few paragraphs)
Let's take two different examples. In the first one, a woman around age 23 comes down with an NTD (pick one) which in the long-term impacts her fertility. She might or might not have kids yet, but she's pretty much guaranteed to live in a society where a lot of a woman's worth is measured by her ability to have children. So the illness which might have affected the man in terms of his ability to do work, has a different societal result/stigma for a woman (because, funny enough, the men arenever infertile, right? ugh).
In the second example, an infant has contracted cholera, a quasi-NTD. Or really any form of water-borne diarrheal disease. In the realistic world, the mother of the child will be responsible for the infant's continued existence. Does she know how to make oral re-hydration fluid? Is this child her first? How will caring for this very needy child impact her other productivity in life? This is different from her hypothetical husband, on whose head the financial ability to pay for the hoped-for child is laid.
Which disease? You know as well as me that different climates/population densities equate to different diseases.
6. Where in Latin America do NTD's have the most drastic effect(s)?
7. What are the effects of natural disasters such as the recent earth quaker in Haiti on the spread of NTD's?
8. How do you feel that implementation of programs to help out with NTDs differs from Latin America to other resource-poor areas?
I think that it is both harder and easier to implement public health measures in Latin America. It is harder because the history most of the countries in Latin America have with "beneficial interventions" as economic as structural adjustment and as military as the USA support of autocratic regimes in favor of more popular leftist movements. So the people of Latin America are, understandably, cautious about accepting anything. I believe the phrase is "no really, look the gift-horse in the mouth" or "okay that's great...what's the catch?"
It is easier for a very simple reason: most of Latin America speaks the same language, which happens to be easy to learn. Resources can be shared that much quicker, and scientific research can be shared in the lingua franca (of a sort) of the region. It democratizes the data, which matters more than you could realize.
9. How might further attention be drawn to these diseases in developed countries (like the USA) so funding could be secured?
This is shallow and smacks of extorting a religious group, but I'm all for re-emphasizing that NTDs, for the most part, are "the Biblical diseases." These are the proximate causes for many of the dietary taboos in the Old Testament--you can catch some pretty nasty things from eating pigs, actually--and used as examples of the holiness of Jesus Christ in the New Testament. I think that you should remind Christians, a major donor group in the USA and elsewhere, of these diseases from the book that haven't gone away, even if we move around by airplane instead of donkeys these days.
10. So "The Big Four" or NTDs? We can't possible solve them all!
Why not? Why not fix them all? The only disease we really don't have a "cure" for is HIV/AIDS. The rest all have documented mechanisms for cure or stopping the transmission of them. Once you change the paradigm of international public health programs from "cutting our losses" to "what's next?" (Oh, President Bartlett, you West Wing fox) the entire financial game gets switched around. An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure in these cases. The tricky part isn't curing the diseases: it's herding politicians (like cats) into realizing that thinking ahead is better than mopping up behind.
11. how do we (the people working towards prevention and eradication) get past the circularity of this issue?You embrace it. You don't just try to solve one thing at a time. You employ people from different disciplines to work together on projects. With today's technology, they don't even have to be in the same country to work with each other. You realize that smaller strides in a bunch of things make for greater strides of the whole. In colloquial terms, the whole becomes greater than the sum of its parts.
12. how might present international institutions be utilized to aid NTD prevention efforts?Well, having the UN make some new "millenium" goals would be helpful, ones that involve NTDs. It doesn't really do anything specific, but public health officials occasionally remind themselves of the bigger picture. NTDs should be in that bigger picture. Also, the WHO and PAHO would behoove themselves to remain in-touch with their NTD divisions which already exist.
13. Were an institution such as the RIO group to decide to eradicate any ONE NTD in the next decade, what one would you recommend and why?Chagas Disease. Not because it's the most pervasive but because they are so close to doing so already, and the mechanisms a public health campaign uses to eradicate Chagas can be repeated in almost the same way for other diseases later on. Also, the world needs another public health victory: like smallpox. But smallpox actually had a magic bullet cure. A victory in the fight against Chagas would signal to the world that the RIO Group had their stuff together public health-wise and could continue onward curing other diseases.
Also, it might just be nice to get rid of something with such a high DALY (Disease adjusted life years) rate.
14. what role does education (both in developed and undeveloped nations) play in this issue?It seems trite, but the first step to curing something is admitting you have a problem. NTDs are neglected mostly because people honestly have never heard of them before, or if they have, only in the context of history/fiction/mythology. Educating people in developed countries helps them make better funding decisions and become educated donors (remember how mommy trains people to donate certain amounts every year? it works like that). Education helps those in resource-access-poor countries twofold: first it helps educate them about good public health habits, and on a more anthropological/psychological level, it helps to give people an etiology (understanding of causation, look it up) to adhere to. Having their illnesses acknowledged and discussed openly takes away some of the psychological distress they might have been feeling.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)